Repair, extend, or rebuild?

Three quite different pieces of work get discussed as though they were one decision. Separating them usually reveals that the cheapest option solves the actual problem.

Talk to us about your site

Repair when the problem is in the pages: message, proof, contact, speed. Extend when the problem is that pages are missing: services, areas, questions unanswered. Rebuild only when the foundation itself is the limit. Most businesses that plan a rebuild need one of the first two.

Three kinds of work, one word

People say redesign to mean anything from rewriting a homepage to replacing everything. That vagueness is expensive, because the largest of the three gets bought when the smallest was needed.

Repair changes what is on the pages. Extension adds pages that do not exist. Rebuild replaces the foundation. They differ enormously in cost, risk and time.

What repair fixes

Almost everything that affects conversion. The message at the top, evidence beside prices, contact visibility, form length, image weight, next steps at the end of pages.

This work is fast, low risk, and acts on visitors who are already arriving, which is why it usually pays before anything else has even started.

What extension fixes

Everything caused by pages that do not exist. If people search for a service you offer and no page addresses it, no amount of redesigning the homepage will help.

Extension is slower to pay because search visibility takes time, and it compounds, which makes it the most durable of the three.

  • A page for each service, named the way customers name it.
  • Area pages where you can write something genuinely local.
  • Answers to the questions your enquiries keep asking.
  • Case studies and evidence that do not currently exist.
  • Cost information where there is none.

What only a rebuild fixes

Foundation problems: unfixable speed, inability to edit, poor mobile behaviour that cannot be corrected, content search engines cannot read, or unmaintained technology.

The distinguishing feature is that no amount of writing or editing removes them. If a problem survives every reasonable attempt to fix it in place, that is a foundation problem.

The risk difference is large

Repair and extension are additive and reversible. A rebuild replaces everything at once, including whatever was quietly working, and it puts your existing search visibility at risk if the addresses and content are not carried across carefully.

This asymmetry is why the order matters. Repair first, extend second, and rebuild only when something genuinely cannot be solved otherwise.

A short test

Take the three problems costing you the most and ask, of each, whether it could be fixed by changing words and images on the existing pages. If yes, that is repair.

If not, ask whether it could be fixed by adding new pages. If yes, that is extension. Only what remains after those two questions is an argument for rebuilding.

How Licheo decides

We run that test before proposing anything, because a rebuild sold where a repair was needed is expensive for the client and produces a worse result than the cheaper work would have.

Where a rebuild is right, the existing content and addresses are treated as assets to carry across rather than as things to start again from.

Part of a larger guide

This page is one part of Redesign and revenue. The other parts:

Questions people ask

Should I fix my website or rebuild it?
Fix when the problem is in the pages, extend when pages are missing, and rebuild only when the foundation is the limit. Most businesses planning a rebuild actually need one of the first two.
How do I tell the difference?
Take your three biggest problems and ask whether each could be fixed by changing words and images on existing pages, then whether it could be fixed by adding pages. Only what remains argues for rebuilding.
Which pays back fastest?
Repair, because it acts on visitors already arriving. Extension pays more slowly and compounds. A rebuild pays indirectly, by removing a limit on everything else.
Is rebuilding riskier?
Considerably. Repair and extension are additive and reversible. A rebuild replaces everything at once, including whatever was quietly working, and it risks existing visibility if content and addresses are not carried across carefully.
Can I do all three?
In sequence, yes, and that is often the sensible plan: repair now for immediate returns, extend over the following months, and rebuild later if a genuine foundation limit remains.

Buy the work you actually need

We run the test before proposing anything, because a rebuild sold where a repair was needed produces a worse result at a higher price.

Talk to us about your site Read the full guide