Reviews and directories for flooring companies: what the assistants check, and what the rules allow
The directories that appeared in 20 Gemini answers about flooring companies, the US and Canadian rules on reviews, Google's own policy, and a simple way to ask every customer.
See if customers can find youBefore naming a flooring company, Gemini searched for its reviews: 36 of its 84 searches in our test contained the word review. The third-party sites it used most were Houzz (8 of 20 answers), Angi, Thumbtack and Best Pick Reports (6 each), HomeAdvisor (5), the Better Business Bureau (3) and HomeStars (3, in Canada). A flooring company should ask every customer for a review, offer nothing in return, reply to reviews, and keep the same name and phone number on each directory.
Why do reviews matter to an AI assistant?
A careful customer looks an installer up before calling. Gemini did the same in our test. In our test of 8 November 2026, it answered 20 questions about flooring companies in 10 cities with 84 Google searches, and 36 of them contained the word review. 17 of the 20 answers ran at least one such search, and in 5 answers Gemini searched 22 companies one at a time: the company's name followed by reviews, or followed by BBB.
Then it used what it found. Of 390 statements in the answers, 91 rested only on third-party sites and 18 on both kinds of source. These were the statements about ratings, review counts, the Better Business Bureau rating, and what customers praised: communication, clean job sites, crews arriving on time.
Google Maps works on the same evidence. Google's help page on local ranking says that prominence is based on information like "how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have", and that "more reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking."
Which directories did Gemini use for flooring companies?
The table lists every third-party site that appeared in more than one of our 20 answers. Each figure is the number of answers that used the site at least once. HomeStars appeared only in Canadian cities. Yelp, Facebook and Nextdoor appeared in none of the 20 answers.
These counts describe one day and one version of Gemini, the developer version with Google Search turned on. Another day may give other sites. Still, the list is a useful order of work for a flooring company that has limited time: complete the profiles that the assistant read, in the countries where you work.
| Site | Answers that used it (of 20) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Houzz | 8 | Both countries |
| Angi | 6 | United States |
| Thumbtack | 6 | United States |
| Best Pick Reports | 6 | United States |
| HomeAdvisor | 5 | United States |
| Birdeye | 4 | Both countries |
| Better Business Bureau | 3 | Both countries |
| HomeStars | 3 | Canadian cities only |
| 2 | Canadian cities only | |
| Yelp, Facebook, Nextdoor | 0 | Not used in any answer |
What does the law say about rewarding reviews in the United States?
In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, numbered 16 CFR Part 465, took effect on 21 October 2024. It covers fake reviews, bought reviews, reviews by insiders, company-controlled review websites and review suppression.
The section on buying reviews, 465.4, says it is a violation "for a business to provide compensation or other incentives in exchange for, or conditioned expressly or by implication on, the writing or creation of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative". In plain words: a flooring company may not offer a discount, a gift card or a free service for a positive review.
The section on review suppression, 465.7, forbids an "unfounded or groundless legal threat", intimidation, or a public false accusation used to stop a review or have it removed. It also forbids presenting the reviews on a website as most or all of the reviews received when negative ones were held back because of their rating. A flooring company that shows a page of reviews should therefore show the bad with the good, or say plainly how reviews were chosen.
What does Canada's Competition Bureau say about reviews?
In Canada, the Competition Bureau enforces the rules on misleading advertising. Its notice "Five-star fake out", published on 2 March 2022, describes the practices it treats as fake reviews: companies that "encourage their employees to post reviews", that "give customers incentives to leave positive reviews", or that "hire a firm to post fake reviews for them". It invites consumers to report fake reviews to the Bureau.
For a Canadian flooring company the practical rule is the same as in the United States. Reviews should come from real customers, written freely, with nothing offered in return, and staff should not review their own employer. This page gives general information; a company with a specific legal question should ask a lawyer.
What does Google's own review policy allow?
Google's policy for content on Maps is stricter than many owners expect. It forbids offering incentives "such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services" for a review. It forbids reviews based on a conflict of interest, which includes "current or former employment". And it forbids businesses to "discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers".
That last rule matters. Some review tools ask the customer first whether they were happy, then send only the happy ones to Google. Google's policy calls this selective soliciting. The same policy allows a business to "solicit or encourage the posting of content that does represent a genuine experience, without offering incentives". Asking every customer is allowed and wise.
Google enforces this with automated systems. In April 2025 Google reported that it "blocked or removed more than 240 million policy-violating reviews" in 2024, and that it shows warnings on some profiles after removing suspicious five-star reviews.
How should a flooring company ask for reviews?
A good moment in flooring is the day the job is finished, when the customer is standing on the new floor. Here is a routine that respects every rule above and takes two minutes per job.
- Ask every customer, at the end of every job, with no question first about whether they were happy.
- Send one short message the same day with a direct link to the Google review form, and a second link to Houzz or HomeStars.
- Offer nothing in return: no discount, no draw, no gift card.
- Ask the customer to mention what was done and where, for example the floor, the rooms and the town, because those details help the next reader.
- Never write a review for a customer, and never let staff or family review the company.
- Send one reminder after a week at most, then stop.
What makes a flooring review useful to the next customer?
A review that says "Great job, thanks!" tells the next reader that one customer was happy. A review that says "They removed old carpet and installed vinyl plank in three bedrooms in Eastbrook, finished in two days and left the house clean" gives facts to two readers at once. The next customer learns what the company does and where. An assistant that searches for the company's reviews finds the floor, the rooms, the town and the time, which are the same facts it looks for on the website.
A company may not write the review or reward it, and it should never ask for a positive one. It may ask every customer, in the same words, to describe what was done. A short message works: "If you have a minute, we would be grateful for a review. It helps other homeowners if you mention the floor, the rooms and your town."
Over a year, reviews written this way build a public record of real jobs in real towns. In our test, the third-party statements Gemini made about flooring companies were built from exactly this kind of record: what customers praised, how many reviews there were, and the rating.
How should a flooring company reply to reviews?
Replies are read by the next customer, and they show how the company behaves when something goes wrong. A short reply to each positive review, naming the job ("Thank you, we enjoyed working on your oak stairs in Eastbrook"), adds a real detail to the page.
A negative review needs a calm, factual reply, written a day later and never in anger. Thank the customer, state the facts without blaming, and offer to fix the problem by phone. Never threaten a reviewer with legal action to remove a review: in the United States that can break section 465.7 of the FTC rule, and anywhere it reads badly to every future customer.
Then, when the problem is fixed, the customer may choose to update the review. That choice must stay theirs, with nothing offered in exchange.
How should a flooring company keep its directory profiles?
A directory profile helps only when it is complete and matches the website. For each directory in the table above that serves your country, claim the profile, then fill in the same name, phone number, address or service area, floors, jobs, years in business and photos as the website. Link the profile to the homepage.
Gemini joined directory reviews to companies by their names. If the website says one name and the directory another, or the phone numbers differ, the join is uncertain. Keep one list of all the profiles with their login details, and update every one of them on the day a fact changes.
Part of a larger guide
This page is one part of Flooring company marketing. The other parts:
Questions people ask
- Which review sites matter most for a flooring company in AI answers?
- In our test of 20 Gemini answers about flooring companies on 8 November 2026, Houzz appeared in 8 answers, Angi, Thumbtack and Best Pick Reports in 6 each, HomeAdvisor in 5, Birdeye in 4, the Better Business Bureau in 3, and HomeStars in 3 Canadian answers. Yelp, Facebook and Nextdoor appeared in none. The flooring companies' own websites appeared in all 20 answers.
- Can a flooring company give a discount in exchange for a review?
- No. In the United States, section 465.4 of the FTC rule on consumer reviews forbids compensation or other incentives in exchange for reviews expressing a particular sentiment. Google's Maps policy forbids incentives such as payment, discounts, free goods or services for any review. Canada's Competition Bureau lists incentives for positive reviews among the practices behind fake reviews. Ask freely and offer nothing.
- Is it allowed to ask only happy customers for a Google review?
- No. Google's policy for Maps content forbids businesses to discourage or prohibit negative reviews or to selectively solicit positive reviews from customers. A tool that asks customers whether they were satisfied and then sends only the satisfied ones to Google does exactly that. The same policy allows a business to ask for reviews that reflect a genuine experience, so ask every customer the same way.
- When did the FTC rule on fake reviews take effect?
- The Federal Trade Commission's Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, took effect on 21 October 2024, according to the official federal regulations database. It covers fake or false reviews, buying reviews, insider reviews, company-controlled review websites, review suppression and fake indicators of social media influence. It applies to businesses in the United States.
- Can flooring company employees review their own company?
- They should not. Google's Maps policy treats a review based on a conflict of interest, including current or former employment, as not allowed. The FTC rule in the United States has a section on insider reviews, and Canada's Competition Bureau names companies that encourage their employees to post reviews among the sources of fake reviews. Reviews should come only from customers.
- How should a flooring company respond to a bad review?
- Reply a day later, calmly. Thank the customer, state the facts without blame, and offer to fix the problem by phone. Never threaten legal action to remove the review: section 465.7 of the FTC rule forbids unfounded legal threats and intimidation used to suppress reviews in the United States. If the problem is fixed, the customer may update the review freely.
- Does Gemini look up a flooring company's reviews before recommending it?
- In our test, yes. Of the 84 Google searches Gemini ran to answer 20 flooring questions, 36 contained the word review, and in 5 answers Gemini searched 22 companies one at a time, by name followed by reviews or BBB. In the Phoenix answer to our first question, Gemini ran a separate search for each of six companies before writing its list.
- Is HomeStars useful for Canadian flooring companies?
- In our test, HomeStars appeared as a source in 3 of the 20 Gemini answers, and all 3 were for Canadian cities: we asked about Toronto, Calgary, Vancouver and Ottawa. Houzz also appeared in Canadian answers. A Canadian flooring company should claim its HomeStars and Houzz profiles, fill them in with the same facts as its website, and ask customers to review there as well.
- Should a flooring company show reviews on its own website?
- Yes, with care. Gemini quoted reviews shown on company websites in our test. In the United States, section 465.7 of the FTC rule forbids presenting displayed reviews as most or all reviews received when negative ones were held back because of their rating. Show reviews with their source and date, include the critical ones, or say plainly how the reviews on the page were chosen.
- How many fake reviews did Google remove from Maps in 2024?
- Google reported on its blog in April 2025 that in 2024 it blocked or removed more than 240 million policy-violating reviews, most before anyone saw them, and that it uses AI to detect fake five-star reviews and to warn users about profiles where suspicious reviews were removed. For a flooring company, a review bought today is a review that can disappear, along with trust.
Sources
- 16 CFR Part 465, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (version history), Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. Effective 21 October 2024, accessed 8 November 2026.
- 16 CFR 465.4, Buying positive or negative consumer reviews, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. Accessed 8 November 2026.
- 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. Accessed 8 November 2026.
- Five-star fake out, Competition Bureau Canada. Published 2 March 2022, accessed 8 November 2026.
- Maps user contributed content policy, Google. Accessed 8 November 2026.
- New ways AI helps keep business information trustworthy, Google (Ian Leader). Published 7 April 2025, accessed 8 November 2026.
- Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help. Accessed 8 November 2026.
Keep reading
See what customers find when they look you up
The free Get Found Check reads your homepage and returns a letter grade with three to five quick fixes in under 60 seconds. If you want the website, the profile and the directories handled for you, contact us for pricing.
See if customers can find you Talk to us about your site